
Who: Dylan Moran
Where: Playhouse
When: Mon 10 and Tues 11 August
How Much: £20
In 140 characters or less: “Dylan Moran: a slightly unhinged genius walking the fine line between madness and comic brilliance.”
After nearly a year and a half on the road in support of his latest show, What It Is, Dylan Moran finally returns to his adopted hometown of Edinburgh for a two-night stand at the Playhouse at the height of the Festival. Yet anticipation and excitement are tempered by apprehension after a slew of mixed reviews for the current tour. The Irishman has recently been accused of looking disinterested on stage, disconnected from his audience, of giving the impression that gigs are an ordeal to be endured, a tiresome distraction between glasses of wine.
Not so tonight. Whether invigorated by the energy of a hometown crowd or simply feeding off the buzz of the city during the Fringe, Moran is electric. Eloquent, intense and engaging, he seizes on audience cues and improvises freely. A cough, a heckle, the sight of cameraphone set him off on meandering tangents. The ad-libbed sections never feel out of place though he sheepishly confesses to losing track of the script on more than one occasion.
As ever, Moran’s stage persona is an amalgam of Bernard Black, his celebrated Black Books character, and a disillusioned existentialist philosopher, neatly pickled in wine. Rather than relying on jokes and punchlines, the Irishman blends the mundane with the surreal, his astute observations balanced by wonderfully absurd mixed metaphors and witty wordplay. And while his yarns rarely hold up well to re-telling, every so often a single phrase reduces the audience to tears of laughter.
Nowhere is his subtle brand of humour better showcased than his Scottish-themed material, apparently written specially for the brace of Edinburgh shows. He gently probes the rivalry between the capital and Glasgow. However, rather than falling back on the Glaswegian stereotype perpetuated by the likes of Frankie Boyle, Moran instead celebrates the virtues of the West Coast city before coyly informing the audience that, “The difference between Glasgow and Edinburgh is, well, Edinburgh is like the beginning of a wedding. Glasgow is what’s left afterwards.”
Moran is well capable of holding his own against other performers when it comes to politics, science and other staple topics but is at his best when dealing with more human issues — pleasure, pain, life, death, love, sex — and lifting the veil on his personal life. His comic threads are spun from whimsy and anecdote and weave a colourful tapestry that exposes the deeply-buried, and often hilarious, truths about human relationships and behaviour.
Yet for all his post-modern, deconstructivist bluster, Moran’s rambling tales are ultimately life-affirming, underpinned by a genuine warmth and a sense that, in spite of all else, love, family and guilty pleasures are at the heart of what makes us human and are to be cherished. While the main set peters out rather than coming to a satisfactory conclusion, a superb encore more than makes amends for any shortcomings. In a show lasting an hour and a half — half as long again as the standard What It Is set — Dylan Moran is a constant delight, a slightly unhinged genius walking the fine line between madness and comic brilliance.
Festbuzz Rating:
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Words: Jodi Mullen







